"God bless Mr. [Kevin] Costner, he was like, 'No – you're going to dye it,'" Annable recalled to PEOPLE Dave Annable is embracing his natural salt and pepper look! In an exclusive conversation with PEOPLE at the season 2 premiere of Lioness on Oct.

On some level, both shows are familial dramas that center on a King Lear-esque patriarch whose children vie for control of their inheritance -- the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, in the case of Taylor Sheridan's mega-popular neo-Western drama-- while also warding off the vultures circling from the outside.